The Search For a Good Sugar Cookie
March 13th, 2008I will just say it right now, I am NOT a fan of the sugar cookie.
Never have been, but hopefully will be some day. Actually, I have taken it
on as a challenge. Today, I baked a standard sugar cookie. I baked it on
stoneware, stoneware with parchment, an aluminum cookie pan, you name it,
I tried it. Much to my dismay, it didn’t really matter, I still was not the biggest fan. I even played
around with thickness, which I did tend to like a thinner variety. When they are thick, they taste kind
of raw and have a bad texture. So, I decided to play with icing.
I will tell you another secret, I am NOT a big fan of icing either…..especially that of which is usually on
a sugar cookie. And today, I made the typical sugar cookie icing, with confectioners sugar, milk, vanilla and corn syrup. I was not impressed. It was way to sugary, and tasted kind of like what liquid chalk might taste like.
That being said, I guess my search is still on. I guess I should also mention that the sugar cookies in the store, yes, those really thick ones with the awful colored frosting and of course with sprinkles, well, I hate those too. Yes, I know I know, most people think they are sinfully delicious, but to me, they are just a dose of sugar that usually leaves me feeling bleh. I would much rather have a chocolate chip cookie, or even a molasses cookie. Call me crazy, call me weird, but, I promise, I am still up to the challenge.